Home Scandal and Gossip Hacked celebs lawyers threaten to sue Google for $100M. Do they have...

Hacked celebs lawyers threaten to sue Google for $100M. Do they have a case?

SHARE
Hacked celebs lawyers threaten to sue Google for $100M
Do lawyers have a legal case against Google?

What counts for privacy, what counts for public domain, what counts for accountability and what counts for freedom of speech? These are some of the questions that are up for grabs as lawyers for hacked female celebrities in the celebgate scandal are threatening to sue Google for $100 million for allegedly failing to remove ‘infringing’ images and ‘making millions from the victimization of women.’

The threat of legal action comes as many of Hollywood’s illustrious stars including Jennifer Lawrence (for a third time), Amber Heard (see new images here) supermodel Cara Delevingne (see images here), Kelli Garner (see images here), Brooke Burns and Rachel Nichols (see images here), Candice Swanepoel (see images here), Kaley Cuoco (see new images here), Kim Kardashian (see images hereKate Bosworth (see images here), Lake Bell and Vanessa Hudgens amongst many other  have in the recent weeks seen illicitly gotten images of themselves distributed online.

The Fappening. When will hackers stop releasing Celebgate images?

Fappening: (NSFW) French actresses Elodie Varlet and Salome Stevenin naked

(NSFW) Erin Heatherton, Cat Deeley, Erin Cummins naked leaked

(NSFW) Real Housewives of Miami Joanna Krupa naked leaked.

Winona Ryder naked unconfirmed trades on DevilsFruit and FappeningDiscussion

Celebgate. Why did the web salivate over the 4chan leaked photos?

Jennifer Lawrence naked: TheFappening and misogynism.

Reddit made a ton of money with TheFappening. But so what? 

Jennifer Lawrence naked. Why we took down the images. 

Reddit bans TheFappening after new Jennifer Lawrence leak threats. 

Why you should click on Jennifer Lawrence naked pictures if you want to. 

Jennifer Lawrence naked photos. Are websites legally obliged to take down? 

Porn sites refuse to take down Jennifer Lawrence naked leaked images 

According to an exclusive via the nypost, Hollywood top lawyer Marty Singer who represents many of the women embroiled in the scandal has vowed to bring search engine Google to account for its failure to take down images despite repeated requests to do so.

Tells the nypost: Marty Singer, who represents over a dozen of the women affected by the leak, has written a sternly-worded letter to Google founders Larry Page and Sergey Brin, as well as Eric Schmidt and Google lawyers accusing them of “blatantly unethical behavior” – and comparing their alleged lack of action to the NFL leadership’s handling of the Ray Rice affair.

The letter, exclusively seen by Page Six claims Google has failed, “to act expeditiously, and responsibly to remove the images, but in knowingly accommodating, facilitating, and perpetuating the unlawful conduct. Google is making millions and profiting from the victimization of women.”

According to Singer, the law firm he which he runs Lavely and Singer first sent Google a notice to remove images four weeks ago and a dozen more, nevertheless many of the images continue to appear on google sites Blogspot and youtube.

Singer adds, ‘Google knows the images are hacked stolen property, private and confidential photos and videos unlawfully obtained and posted by pervert predators who are violating the victims’ privacy rights … Yet Google has taken little or no action to stop these outrageous violations.’

The letter continues, ‘Because the victims are celebrities with valuable publicity rights you do nothing — nothing but collect millions of dollars in advertising revenue … as you seek to capitalize on this scandal rather than quash it. Like the NFL, which turned a blind eye while its players assaulted and victimized women and children, Google has turned a blind eye while its sites repeatedly exploit and victimize these women.’

Of course the $100 million dollar question is does Marty Singer and co have a legal case to go after vendors who decline to take down images after DMCA taken notices have been put to them? Which is to ask if Google wasn’t making money off the images (and naturally everything else it runs on its search engine) would lawyers still seek to go after the outlet? Are lawyers fighting for the right of their client’s privacy and the ownership of intangibles? Can anyone really lay claim to an intangible such as an image and what happens when that image becomes widely disseminated in the public domain and the uber void of cyberspace, can any celebrity or public figure lay claim or ownership on such intangibles, irrespective of the morality of the issues aside?

Notes businessinsider: To be fair to Google, its staff don’t choose what the search engine turns up on the net. The system is an algorithm that simply detects what other people have published.

Which posits the question should google be forced into now becoming the moral barometer of what is morally correct and what can and can not appear on the web, assuming one has a cache of high net worth individuals who can fund a legal case (never mind the countless other illicit images of women that will continue to remain on the web for lack of litigation financial stamina)?

The Fappening: Message from hackers: there is more to come

(NSFW) Lizzy Caplan and Carly Pope naked via Fappening 3.

Brooke Burns and Rachel Nichols naked via Fappening 3

(NSFW) T mobile model, Carly Foulkes naked via Fappening 3.

 Jennifer Lawrence naked via Fappening 3: Social media disappointed

And then there were these comments on the web that made me wonder:

I would like to know how any of them can claim copyright infringement? Did they turn in a copyright, trademark, or patent application? If so sure would like to see proof of them. Otherwise using copyright as the reason for removal is straight fraud and abuse of the DMCA process. Sound as if they want removal just because, which is not a valid excuse last time I checked.

What a gift that keeps on giving is the DMCA to sleazy lawyers. What an unnecessary cost of doing business for Google. Hello? Google is a link farm. It does not post nude images of anyone, it just lets you know where they are. Do the lawyers go after all the web search engines or just the one with deep pockets.

I actually won’t criticize the stupid US lawmakers too much, the law is being misused. The EU with their ‘right to be forgotten’ makes DMCA almost seem sane; however, both abuse the messenger for the message.

Who is going to compensate Google for the hectic, nearly impossible work to clean up the mess for them?

Why do the celebrities and their handlers think that they can put the cat back into the bag?

Most likely they will have to live with the fact that in nude they look very much like just common people, nothing glamorous.

This is ridiculous. It’s Apple’s fault and yet they want to sue Google instead of Apple. Whoever believes this “brute force” story is just plain stupid. Even if we are talking about 50 coordinated hackers it would take waaaay to much time and resources to hack that many accounts via “brute force”. They have found a loop hole in Apple’s cloudsystem and Apple is hiding facts.

Google’s inability to remove all copies of the images and keep them from being reposted isn’t really even their fault. It is the nature of the internet. If they are ignoring take-down notices that are specific enough to act upon, then that is their fault. However it the notice isn’t specific enough to act upon, or the images keep getting reposted in a format that has been modified enough to make it difficult to automatically identify them, that is not Google’s fault.

If you take a naked picture of yourself and save it on a server you have no control of or if you think you are going to transfer those images via the internet or any network you don’t own or control, it is your own fault for not thinking. It’s fine if you want take naked pictures of yourself, but you need to think about how to keep them in a controlled environment. Are we suing lock makers because someone has figured out how to break into them and steal our stuff? Maybe the insurance companies need to get a new product out to cover this. And don’t’ naked pictures usually get celebrity more money by exposure, I wonder if this actually helps their career more than harms. And lastly who the heck thinks Google is going to be be able to police the entire internet?

(NSFW) Kelli Garner naked via The Fappening 3.

(NSFW) The Fappening 3: Amber Heard Naked. New images released.

The Fappening 3: Jennifer Lawrence naked; 55 new images released

(NSFW) Cara Delevingne naked leaked via 4chan. But are they fake?

Anna Kendrick leaked in Fappening part 3. Drugs galore.

Emma Watson naked hoax: Anonymous to go after Rantic

Celebgate photo hacker ring likely to be US based says FBI

Emma Watson naked hoax: A hoax within a hoax…

Celebgate. Why did the web salivate over the 4chan leaked photos?

Olga Lyulchak, Ukrainian politician laughs off her naked leaked images.

(NSFW) Emily Ratajkowski and Candice Swanepoel naked via 4chan.

(NSFW) Rihanna naked leaks via 4chan? No comment…

(NSFW) Amber Heard naked leak pictures via 4chan too?

(NSFW) New Scarlett Johansson naked leaked pictures via old hack.

Jennifer Lawrence naked: TheFappening and misogynism.

Jennifer Lawrence and Kim Kardashian nude leaks. Do they deserve it?

(NSFW) Kate Bosworth naked leaked images via 4chan?

(NSFW) Kim Kardashian naked photos leaked by 4chan?

(NSFW) New Jennifer Lawrence naked photos leaked by 4chan?

(NSFW) Vanessa Hudgens naked leaked photos via 4Chan. Yet to confirm

(NSFW) Lake Bell naked pictures leaked via 4chan?

(NSFW) Kaley Cuoco naked once again as Kim Kardashian leak explodes

Kaley Cuoco naked photos: I freaked out when they weren’t fake this time

(NSFW) Kaley Cuoco leaked naked pictures and video.

Candice Swanepoel instagrams bikini bottom and I am dizzy.

Candice Swanepoel Instagram. Victoria’s Secret Bahamas photo shoot. Would you hit it?

Has Victoria’s Secret supermodel Candice Swanepoel gone too far with her new abs instagram picture?

Kirsten Dunst naked photos: ‘I’m just laughing about it.’ Or is she?

(NSFW) Hayden Panettiere naked pictures via 4chan leaked.

(NSFW) Joy Corrigan warned Apple leaked images were stolen. May sue now? 

Hmm, Hayden Panettiere’s breasts look awfully fake to me…

Are Jennifer Lawrence nude pictures for sale? Fappening report under surveillance 

Reddit made a ton of money with TheFappening. But so what? 

(NSFW) Joy Corrigan naked leak pictures via 4chan now hits the tapes.

Jennifer Lawrence nude exhibit cancelled. Artist finds sudden empathy 

Jennifer Lawrence leaked pictures leads to New Zealand internet collapse. 

Jennifer Lawrence naked. Why we took down the images. 

Reddit bans TheFappening after new Jennifer Lawrence leak threats. 

New Jennifer Lawrence naked photos released says TheFappening twitter account

Kaley Cuoco: New leaked naked pictures appear in second released wave 

Jennifer Lawrence naked pics set to appear in gallery show. But is it legal? 

Why you should click on Jennifer Lawrence naked pictures if you want to. 

Jennifer Lawrence naked photos. Are websites legally obliged to take down? 

Porn sites refuse to take down Jennifer Lawrence naked leaked images 

AnonIB: Were Celebgate photos the result of an underground hacking and trading ring? 

TheFappening: McKayla Maroney leaked naked photos are child porn says lawyer 

OriginalGuy, Jennifer Lawrence leaked naked hacker is on the run. 

Apple calls celebrity leak hack a targeted attack not a software flaw 

(NSFW) Victoria Justice leaked naked pictures. Fake or real? 

(NSFW) Ariana Grande leaked naked pictures. Are they fake? 

(NSFW) Mary Elizabeth Winstead leaked naked pictures. Twitter trolls blame her 

(NSFW) Jennifer Lawrence video leaked. Seeking paypal donations 

(NSFW) Brie Larson leaked naked pictures. 

(NSFW) Aubrey Plaza leaked naked pictures. 

(NSFW) Kate Upton leaked naked pictures via 4chan. Threatens to sue. 

(NSFW) Kirsten Dunst leaked naked pictures. Tweets anger at Apple iCloud 

(NSFW) Kaley Cuoco leaked naked pictures and video. 

Selena Gomez topless. Are the hacked photos real?

(NSFW) Jennifer Lawrence naked pictures. 4chan hacker has 50 pictures and erotic video 

Is Scarlett Johansson leaked photos sentence of ten years too harsh?

Computer hacker who leaked nude photos of Scarlett Johansson gets 10 years.

SHARE
Like Scallywagvagabond on Facebook    
  • Shamik Chakravarti

    Isn’t this the problem with these lawyers. Suing the messenger. They don’t have the means or knowhow to trace the hackers, so they blame Google.